Spirit Espirt EL-5 Elliptical

  • Reviewed On: November 30, -0001
  • Reviewed By: Gerard Lao

MSRP: $900, Price As Reviewed: $900, Model Year: 2011

Where To Buy : We Recommend Amazon.com

 

Pros

Treadmills411 Editor Comments

Strong parts warranty of 5 years

The EL-5 comes with a good overall warranty for its price but we'd like to give emphasis about its 5-year parts warranty since it's a rare offering for ellipticals in the sub-$1000 category. A 2-year parts warranty is already acceptable for this price range so having a 5-year guarantee on the El-5's components is something else.

200-lb machine

The EL-5 weighs slightly heavier than many sub-$1000 ellipticals tipping in at 200 pounds but more than this, you may be putting too much stress on this machine since we also feel that the 350-lb maximum user weight capacity may be exaggerated. Our take on this is that there shouldn't be a 100-lb difference between the machine weight and user weight or else you'll be putting  your safety and the EL-5's components into compromise.

30-lb flywheel

Information about the elliptical's flywheel are oftentimes left out for one reason or another. The most common may be  because this would be the last thing a buyer would ask about since it's an internal component. Another feasible reason is that manufacturers put flywheels that aren't too heavy. This is important because the weight of the flywheel determines the smoothness of the stride motion. It's one general notion that if you aren't too proud of something, you'd rather keep mum about it. Same thing goes with the elliptical flywheels for many manufacturers. Fortunately for the EL-5, you have a 30-lb flywheel that's heavier than the average 18lbs to 24lbs commonly found in many ellipticals.

Pedals are cushioned,  oversized with 2 degree inversion, and 3 positions with twist lock pin.

The EL-5 got high scores in our grade cards for their enhanced foot pedals. In fact, this elliptical got full marks because of its oversized and cushioned pedals. It's also adjustable so you can position your feet in a way that's comfortable for you.

 

Cons

Treadmills411 Editor Comments

Adjustable stride up to 20"

Not having these features are still acceptable for a $900 elliptical but we're listing it here because we've seen other more affordable Spirit ellipticals offer one of these 2 features. It' s just puzzling why this manufacturer has to remove components in their higher model ellipticals. These features would have given you  more comfortable and entertaining workout.

30 degree incline

When you pedal backwards, you focus on your legs' back muscles particularly the quads, glutes, and hamstrings. This would give you a more toned lower body and a firmer butt. Sadly, there's no reverse stride feature available with the EL-255.

Basic Components – 65.2% [View Score Details] [Visit Recommended Merchant]

Quality and Durability – 67.6% [View Score Details] [Visit Recommended Merchant]

Overall Score & Conclusion - 66.4% [View Score Details] [Visit Recommended Merchant]

Category Ranking Criteria Scored As Points Awarded Points Possible Percentage Explanation Notes
Main component Max Stride Length 19"-22" 20 20 100% Comes with a 20\" maximum stride length.
Main component Resistance Levels 20 or more 20 20 100% Elliptical has 20 levels of resistance.
Main component Max Incline/Ramp None 0 15 0% Incline feature not stated.
Main component Programs 8 12 25 48% Has 8 total programs including 2 heart rate-controlled programs.
Main component Fan No/Not Stated 3 10 30% No cooling fans.
Main component Water Bottle Holder Yes 10 10 100% Comes with bottle holder.
Main component Foot Pedal Motion and Type Adjustable, cushioned, ergonomical 30 30 100% Pedals are cushioned, oversized with 2 degree inversion, and 3 positions with twist lock pin.
Main component Handlebar Grips Enhanced/Side Handrails 10 10 100% Features a high-density, sweat-resistant rubber grips.
Main component Reverse Stride Motion No 3 10 30% No mention of reverse stride motion.
Main component Time Display Yes 5 5 100% Console displays calories burned, distance, speed, time, and heart rate.
Main component Distance/Strides Display Yes 5 5 100% Console displays distance.
Main component Calories Display Yes 5 5 100% Console displays calories burned, distance, speed, time, and heart rate.
Main component Console Design Modern or Intuitive 10 10 100% Comes with a large blue backlit LCD with alpha-numeric message.
Main component Self Improvement: Fitness Tests/Competition/Goals No/Not Stated 1.5 5 30% No mention of Fitness tests/Goals.
Main component Personalization: User Profiles/Progress Logs/History No/Not Stated 1.5 5 30% None stated to qualify for this category.
Main component Heart Rate Monitor Grip 10 20 50% Comes with pulse grips only.
Main component MP3 Player Support No/Not Stated 5 20 25% No MP3 player feature.
Main component TV No/Not Stated 5 25 20% No TV feature mentioned.
Main component Money Back Guarantee Yes (30 days or less) 15 20 75% Amazon.com provides a 30-day money back guarantee on its products.
Main Component Bonus Handlebar Design Fixed and Moving 5     Has both fixed and moving handllebars.
    Subtotal 1: 176 270 65.19%  


:
Category Ranking Criteria Scored As Points Awarded Points Possible Percentage Explanation Notes
Quality and reliability Frame warranty 13 to lifetime 25 25 100% Amazon description states frame comes with a lifetime warranty.
Quality and reliability Brakes warranty 13 to lifetime 10 10 100% Manufacturer warranty is lifetime on brakes.
Quality and reliability Parts warranty 5 years 45 60 75% Parts warranty is 5 years.
Quality and reliability Labor warranty 1 year 20 60 33.33% Manufacturer gives a 1 year warranty on labor.
Quality and reliability Unit Weight (lbs) 188-200 20 40 50% Elliptical weighs 200 pounds.
Quality and reliability Max User Weight 338 to 350 pounds 32.5 40 81.25% Has a user capacity of 350 pounds.
Quality and reliability Flywheel Weight (lbs) 30 or more 20 20 100% Weight of flywheel is 30 pounds.
    Subtotal 2 : 172.5 255 67.65%  
    Overall: 348.5 525 66.4%